Hole By Hole
I
t's about golf.


The Handicap Stroke Allocation Service
Make sure the golfers on your course can use their handicap strokes
where they need them the most!


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Note to Netscape Users: Please read the questions in order.
The "Top of Page" tag at the end of each question works, but the quick-jump link
to each question doesn't working correctly on some Netscape Browsers.  Thanks for your patience.
top

1. What is a "hole-by-hole handicap ranking"?

2. How are these handicap allocations used?

3. Are these handicap rankings intended to help the lesser-skilled player win these holes?

4. Aren't these holes simply ranked by how hard it is to make par on them? If not, why doesn't that method work?

5. We've had the same handicap allocations on our course for years. Why should we change them?

6. Can you give us an example of what can happen if the handicap allocations are done correctly?

7. We don't have regular playing members because we're a resort course. Why should we update our handicap allocations?

8. How often should the handicap allocations be re-evaluated, once they are done correctly?


1. What is a "hole-by-hole handicap ranking"?
A golf scorecard shows you which hole you're playing, the par score for each hole, and the handicap ranking for each hole. These handicap rankings are used in many types of golf competitions and amateur tournaments. For example, here's a detail from a typical scorecard:

Hole No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
White Tees        380 474 400 179 346 326 310 471 147
Handicap Ranking 4 18 2 8 10 12 14 6 16
Par 4 5 4 3 4 4 4 5 3
                                                                                         
Hole No. 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
White Tees        198 424 327 142 387 363 164 513 431
Handicap Ranking 7 1 11 17 3 13 15 9 5
Par 3 4 4 3 4 4 3 5 4
                                                                                            

To Top of Page

2. How are these handicap allocations used?
For example, Player A, with an 12 handicap, is playing his buddy, Player B, who has a 20 handicap. Player A therefore gives Player B eight strokes to make up the difference in their handicaps--one each on the holes where the handicap rankings are numbered 1 through 8. On the example in Question 1, then, Player B uses these strokes on Hole Nos. 1, 3, 4, 8, 10, 11, 14, and 18.

To Top of Page

3. Are these handicap rankings supposed to help the lesser-skilled player win these holes?
Not really. According to the USGA, these rankings are actually intended to give the higher-handicap player a chance to match the lower-handicap player. This is sometimes called "halving the hole," or "tying the hole."

To Top of Page

4. Aren't these holes simply ranked by how hard it is to make par on them? If not, why doesn't that method work?
The USGA notes that "Difficulty in making par on a hole is not an effective indicator of the need for a stroke." That's because players of different skill levels frequently play the course very differently, depending on which holes they're playing. While the holes are not supposed to be ranked by total average scores for most competitions, they often are.

However, if the handicap allocations are done correctly, the players compete in a fair contest, with a hole-by-hole allocation that appropriately considers different skill levels.

We also provide a bonus report, called The Hardest Hole Rankings. This special analysis shows you the actual relative difficulty of the holes on your course. The USGA reports that some clubs like to use this kind of ranking for Stableford or four-ball stroke tournaments. Our bonus report follows the USGA's suggested statistical method for this special purpose.

If your course has regular playing members who post their scores, and want to learn a bit more about what we can do for you, go to the Private Course page. If your course doesn't provide for score posting for handicaps, go to the Public Course page.

To Top of Page

5. We've had the same handicap allocations on our course for years. Why should we change them?
Golf courses change over time, and so do the people who play them. Trees grow up and out, crowding the edges of fairways that were once wide. Bunkers change shape after years of players hacking their way out of them. Courses sometimes add trees, remove or replace bunkers, replace fairway grass, or completely redo several or all of the greens.

Members change over time, too. That means the mix of skill levels changes as well. Furthermore, if the hole-by-hole handicap allocations haven't been updated in a long time, chances are that they were never calculated the right way in the first place.

Periodic updates can take all these changes into account and tell you how the allocations should be spread out among the 18 holes. A statistically valid collection of recent scores, properly analyzed, can tell you how the course is currently playing and how the holes should actually be ranked. (That's what Hole By Hole does.)

To Top of Page

6. Can you give us an example of what can happen if the handicap allocations are done correctly?
Sure! Take a look at what happened to the hole-by-hole handicap allocations for Oak Meadow GC, a course in Evansville, Indiana, when Hole By Hole recently updated their rankings:

Hole No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Old Handicap Rank       14 12 8 10 16 6 2 18 4
New Handicap Rank       3 7 9 17 13 1 11 15 5
                                                                                            
Hole No. 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Old Handicap Rank       9 11 7 1 15 5 17 13 3
New Handicap Rank       10 4 18 6 14 2 12 16 8
                                                                                            

To Top of Page

Now On Sale!
The Handicap Stroke Allocation Guide:
Ranking the Holes on Your Golf Course For Fun and Fair Competition

Now only $19.95 (US) per copy (with FREE shipping and handling!)

You'll never look at a golf scorecard the same way ever again.

Click here for a printable order form!


7. We don't have regular playing members because we're a resort course. Why should we update our handicap allocations?
Resort courses have as many if not more reasons to make sure their hole-by-hole handicap allocations are up-to-date. Course conditions change over time on resort courses as well as all other clubs. Also, it's not uncommon for players at resort courses to have a friendly competition among themselves, where handicap strokes are used. If the different skill levels of resort players are properly considered in allocating handicap strokes, the updated rankings will add to the customers' enjoyment of the course. That will enhance repeat business. The fact that these allocations have been recently updated can also be used as part of the marketing plan for the resort course. For more details, go to the
Public Course page.

To Top of Page

8.  How often should the handicap allocations be re-evaluated, once they are done correctly?
Normally, our analysis would be useful and statistically defensible for five years or so. Re-evaluation should be done on a faster schedule if certain conditions change. For example, we recommend a re-evaluation for a member-based course if the membership changes by 30 per cent since the date of our initial evaluation. For all courses, we also recommend a re-evaluation and updating of the handicap stroke allocations if there any sizeable changes in the mix of players or in course conditions. If several greens are re-built, or bunkers on 3 or more holes are re-built, or if the course starts a large tree-cutting campaign, these handicap allocations will most likely need changing.

To Top of Page

Links to Hole By Hole Web Pages

Member, National Golf Foundation
Associate Member


© Frederick Schranck 1997-2001